Scale AI: Five European Complaints Highlight the Surveillance of AI Workers

This is some text inside of a div block.
5
November 18, 2026

Table of contents

Introduction

Behind the spectacular technical performance of artificial intelligence lies a very human reality. To train, test and improve AI models, hundreds of thousands of people perform annotation, evaluation and correction tasks on content produced by algorithms every day.

This model is now coming under scrutiny in Europe. On 27 October 2026, Austrian digital rights organization noyb, working with Intérêt à Agir, DiPLab and Reversing.Works, announced five complaints concerning Scale AI in four countries: France, Italy, the Netherlands and Austria. The complaints notably concern the alleged surveillance of independent workers registered on Outlier, Scale AI's platform.

Beyond the specific case of this US company, the matter highlights a new category of platform workers who contribute, often invisibly, to the development of today's AI systems.

For businesses using artificial intelligence, the allegations also highlight the importance of integrating data protection and regulatory compliance into their AI governance frameworks.

Who Are the Data Workers Behind Artificial Intelligence?

AI models need data to operate, but they also rely on human intervention. Workers may be asked to compare two AI-generated answers, verify their accuracy, label content or write instructions intended to improve model performance.

Outlier forms part of this digital microtask economy. According to Reuters, more than 900,000 freelancers are registered on the platform and contribute training data for customers including Meta, OpenAI and Google.

These workers are generally independent contractors. The model is reminiscent of other digital platforms that have attracted significant attention in recent years, such as ride-hailing and delivery platforms, but applied to the artificial intelligence production chain.

They represent an emerging category of data workers, whose human labour is directly embedded in the AI value chain.

Why Is Scale AI Facing Complaints in Europe?

Allegedly Intrusive Digital Surveillance

The complaints brought by noyb notably concern the amount and nature of personal data allegedly collected about workers using Outlier.‍

According to the allegations reported by Reuters, as many as 19 trackers could monitor workers' activity, including keyboard activity, mouse movements at regular intervals and on-screen activity. Research by DiPLab reportedly indicated that the collected information could even be used to reconstruct a working session in a video-like format.‍

noyb further alleges that trackers associated with services including TikTok, Facebook, LinkedIn, Sprig and Datadog collect various pieces of personal information, including IP addresses, unique identifiers and data concerning pages visited.

These allegations will, however, need to be assessed by the competent authorities reviewing the complaints.

More broadly, the case highlights the need for organizations implementing monitoring technologies for employees or contractors to carefully assess the resulting processing of personal data.

Discover our compliance services

Biometric Data at the Heart of the Concerns

Another sensitive issue concerns worker identification. According to the allegations, individuals using Outlier may be required to provide identity documents and a video of their face to US identity verification provider Persona.

According to Scale AI, the process contributes to verifying workers' identities and qualifications. The complainants notably challenge what they consider to be the repeated and insufficiently justified nature of these checks. noyb also alleges that other information, including geolocation data, may be processed.

The issue is particularly sensitive under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Where biometric data is processed for the purpose of uniquely identifying an individual, it constitutes a special category of personal data under Article 9 GDPR and is subject to enhanced protection.

Organizations using such technologies must therefore carefully assess their necessity and proportionality and identify the appropriate legal conditions for the processing.

Where businesses use biometric or similarly intrusive technologies, a detailed compliance assessment and, where applicable, a Data Protection Impact Assessment (DPIA) can therefore play a central role.

From Delivery Riders to Data Workers: A New Generation of Platform Labour

The case therefore goes beyond privacy alone.

AI platforms can determine which tasks are offered, when they become available and the financial incentives associated with completing them. According to information reported by Reuters, Outlier has offered bonuses of between $100 and $200 for completing 200 tasks within 24 hours.

This raises a question that has become familiar in the platform economy: where does technical intermediation end and the organization of work begin?

The issue is particularly relevant because independent contractor status does not necessarily provide the same social protections as employee status. Through the complaints, the organizations behind the initiative aim to draw attention not only to personal data protection but also more broadly to working conditions and the relationship between platforms and their contributors.‍

GDPR and Worker Surveillance: What Protection for AI Data Workers?

The case also illustrates the growing importance of data protection law in the employment and platform-work context.

The GDPR does not only protect customers, prospects and internet users. It also protects workers when their personal data is processed. Such data can relate to their identity, digital activity or, in certain circumstances, biometric characteristics.

The complaints concerning Scale AI and Outlier have been brought before data protection authorities in four European countries, including the CNIL in France. Their examination could provide further insight into how GDPR principles apply to emerging forms of AI-related platform work.

The principles of data minimisation, transparency, necessity and proportionality are particularly relevant where technologies enable detailed and continuous monitoring of an individual's activity.

Organizations deploying technologies that monitor employees or contractors should therefore integrate these requirements from the design stage and document the resulting decisions.

Scale AI Complaints: Allegations Still to Be Examined

The five complaints do not in themselves establish Scale AI's legal liability.

Scale AI has disputed the privacy allegations and maintains that the relevant platform practices are disclosed to workers.

It is therefore important to distinguish between the allegations made by the complainants and any infringement that may subsequently be established by the competent authorities.

Nevertheless, the complaints raise fundamental questions: how far can a platform go in monitoring its contributors? Under what conditions can it use biometrics? And what protections should be guaranteed to these new digital workers?

The complaints also form part of a broader interdisciplinary initiative focusing on working conditions throughout artificial intelligence value chains.‍

Are Data Workers the Next Major Challenge for AI Regulation?

Following ride-hailing drivers and delivery workers, data workers could represent the next major stage in Europe's debate over work in the platform economy.

As AI becomes increasingly central to the economy, protecting the people whose work makes these systems possible could become just as strategically important as regulating the models themselves.

The Scale AI case therefore illustrates why AI governance cannot focus solely on model performance or EU AI Act compliance. It must also take personal data protection requirements, working conditions and the human consequences of the AI value chain into account.

How DPO Consulting Can Help

Does your organization develop or deploy AI systems involving personal data, employees or contractors? DPO Consulting’s experts can help you combine AI governance, GDPR compliance and regulatory risk management across your AI projects.

Related Services and Resources

Read this next

See all